The 5 Best Pizza Stones of 2021

The 5 Best Pizza Stones of 2021 – Turn your Oven, Grill, or Smoker into a Pizza Oven

Who doesn’t love a good slice of pizza? If you don’t, it is ok; this is a great article to learn more about bakeware or find an excellent gift for a friend. However, if you love pizza, you are probably ready to try your homemade pizza recipes and bake your own pizzas.

Making your own pizzas can be very gratifying; you can choose your own ingredients and cook everything just the way you like it. However, not everyone has a pizza oven or brick oven to cook perfect pizzas at home, don’t worry, introducing baking pizza stones. A good pizza baking stone can turn your gas grill, charcoal grill, and even your home kitchen oven into a working pizza oven. Yes, you can turn your gas or charcoal grill into a pizza oven.


Our Top Picks – Best Pizza Stone


What is a Pizza Stone – Just in Case 🙂

A Pizza Stone is a hard portable baking surface or pan made of ceramic, stone, or metals used in grills, smokers, or ovens to bake crispy-crust pizzas. This kitchen bakeware accessory is what makes pizza dough fluffy and crispy!

Pizza stones are utilized like cookie sheets; one can preheat a pizza stone and bake a pizza and other foods on its cooking surface. However, baking stones and cookie sheets’ main difference is that pizza stones can absorb moisture from the pizza dough, resulting in a crispier pizza crusts.

Pizza stones are designed for baking pizzas in ovens, fire pits, and BBQ grills. 

To cook good pizza at home, you need a stone or baking pan that can absorb moisture and radiate heat efficiently. If you simply throw pizza dough on a hot surface or grill, you will destroy the pizza, burn it and likely end up with a lovely soggy dough disaster.

Pizza stones are an excellent accessory for your charcoal, gas grill, or oven. A pizza stone can turn any charcoal or gas grill into a great pizza oven for a fraction of the cost a real pizza oven.

What Makes a Good Pizza Stone

A good pizza stone will be effective at transferring heat evenly to the pizza dough, absorbing moisture to bake crispier pizzas, and should withstand high temperatures. The materials and methods used to build or manufacture the pizza stone will directly impact the stone’s quality, efficiency, and durability.


Types of Pizza Stones

orange square Ceramic and Clay Pizza Stones

Ceramic and clay pizza stones are the classic and best-known type of baking stones in the culinary market. Ceramic is also used in other bakeware and cooking appliances due to its capacity to absorb and radiate heat. Ceramic stones are easy to manufacture in different shapes and sizes, making them versatile and an easy-fit for kamado grills and ovens alike.   

Pros: 

  • Ceramic and Clay pizza stones absorb and radiate heat well.
  • These stones can be found in different shapes and sizes – Can find options for your grill and kamados
  • Ceramic stones bake crispier pizzas since the stone material can absorb moisture from the pizza dough during baking. 

Cons:

  • These stones typically require to be preheated to become effective at baking and crisping the dough. 
  • If you drop a ceramic or claystone, you can kiss it goodbye. There is no coming back from a drop. 
  • Can absorb oils and other liquids, making these stones hard to clean
  • Most baking stones are not dishware safe, nor can you use detergents to clean them.

 

orange square Cast Iron Pizza Stones

Cast iron is widely used in BBQ grills grates, cookware, and bakeware for its ability to retain and transfer heat. Cast iron is also extremely durable if adequately maintained and, with small amounts of lubrication, can also become a non-stick cooking surface.

Cast Iron Pizza pans can be used in ovens, stoves, open fires, and BBQ grills. Because cast iron is strong and durable, it can be placed on just about any heat source or a cooking appliance.

Cast iron pans are strong. They can handle high temperatures and can even handle open fire.

Although cast iron pans can be virtually bulletproof, they require a bit more maintenance as where stones are pretty much maintenance-free. Cast iron needs to be kept oiled or “seasoned” to avoid rust. Lucky some cast iron products already come pre-seasoned.

Pros: 

  • Cast Iron heats up fast. 
  • Cast iron pans are easier to clean than stone bakeware.
  • This pan has handles, which makes it easier to handle in and out of grills and ovens. 
  • It won’t break or crack under extreme heat.
  • Cast iron is strong, durable, and can take a couple of accidental drops. It can also heat it faster than ceramic stones. 
  • Cast iron cooking accessories can be used on just about any heating source.
  • Some cast-iron baking pans allow you to make deep dish pizza – most stones are flat, cast iron pans can be shaped like skillets

Cons:

  • The main problem with cast iron cooking accessories is that they are heavy. 
  • Cast iron can be damaged when exposed to extreme temperatures.

orange square Cordierite Pizza Stones

Cordierite Pizza Stones are incredibly durable and can be more expensive than other ceramic or cast iron pizza stones. However, cordierite is long-lasting and can withstand high heat and extreme temperature changes. Cordierite bakeware is cable of sustaining dramatic temperature changes without cracking as clay and ceramic can. 

Cordierite stone is extremely strong and heat resistant, but it is a stone and can crack if hit hard enough or dropped.

Pros:

  • Remarkably resistant to temperature changes, meaning if the stone is left outside in the cold, it can be introduced to heat without much issue.
  • Long-lasting material- will not rust or need much maintenance.
  • Cordierite stones can absorb moisture from the pizza dough for a perfectly crispy crust.

Cons: 

  • These stones can be more expensive than clay or ceramic stones.
  • Not as strong as cast iron.

Do pizza stones make a difference?

Pizza stones make a world of difference when making pizzas at home. Ceramic stones’ porous surface is what makes those perfect fluffy and crispy crusts. The stone can absorb moisture from the pizza dough, allowing it to cook better and bake perfectly without hot and cold spots.

Pizza Stones can be preheated to quickly transfer an initial powerful burst of heat to the pizza dough and create a nice puffy and crispy crust.

Another advantage of using Pizza Stones is they can cook more evenly than other baking sheets or grill greats, ensuring your pizza dough cooks entirely and no raw dough is left in your pizza. Unless you have a stone-oven, you will need to use a pizza stone to get good results.

How to Choose the Best Pizza Stone For You

There are many pizza stones in the market and many brands to choose from. In this article, we researched and independently tested our picks, but ultimately, your needs, personal preferences, budget, and equipment you own will determine which pizza stones suites you best. 

However, in our research, we found that ceramic pizza stones perform exceptionally well and are budget-friendly, a combination that many of our readers can find attractive and enjoy.

To choose the best pizza stone for you, consider the type of baking and cooking you’ll be doing. If you are looking for a good but budget-friendly option, ceramic stones are a great choice. If you are serious about cooking pizza, bake pizza often, or run a small pizza shop, then a cordierite pizza stone can be a better choice.

Lastly, don’t forget about cast iron pizza pans. If you are looking for something that will last for years, cast iron baking pans are a good option for you.

What is the best material for a pizza stone? 

Cast iron pans and cordierite pizza stones are the best materials for pizza stones. These materials can take a fair amount of use and withstand high temperatures without incurring any damages. 

Ceramic is an excellent material and makes for great pizza stones, but the stone can crack if exposed to extreme temperature changes.

What should I look for when buying a pizza stone?

pizza on table

orange square Material

Pizza stones can be made from various materials, but the most common materials are cast iron, steel, and stone. Ceramic stones are trendy, but many users also enjoy cast iron due to its strength. Use the information in this article to choose the best pizza stone or pan material. Consider what type of heat source you’ll be using, gas grill, charcoal grill, smoker, oven, or stove; your cooking platform will help you determine what stone materials you should choose.

Pay close attention to the materials used to build the product. See if the brand follows any National Sanitation Foundation (NSF ) protocols. The NSF has published minimum materials standard protocols for bakeware

The NSF Protocol P393 for Oven Bakeware home use establishes minimum food protection and safety requirements, including materials constructions and even design of bakeware and cookware sold to consumers. The list includes pizza pans, cookie sheets, and yes, ceramic stoneware and earthware.

orange square Size and shape

Your pizza stone’s size and shape are important as it is improbable to change the size or shape of a pizza stone once the purchase is made. If you purchase a stone too small and later realize you need a bigger cooking surface, you will have to buy another pizza stone. Take the time to consider what type of baking you will be doing, what kind of pizzas you will be making, and purchase the right-sized product.

Also, consider where you will be using your pizza stone. If you will be cooking in your kitchen oven, Green Egg or on an open fire. If you are using the pizza stone in your smoker grill, you will likely need a rectangular shaped baking stone.

orange square Versatility

Some pizza stones are fragile, limiting how and where you can use them, but others can be used to sizzle, cut the pizza right on the stone, and even store your pizza in your fridge. Some stones can be thrown in a dishwasher, while others require careful cleaning.

Additionally, some pizza stones are so versatile that they can be used on open fires, on your stove, or in fire pits. For example, If you plan on cooking outdoors during a camping trip, a cast iron pizza pan might be more versatile than a ceramic stone. You can use a cast iron pizza pan on an open fire and cook other meals with too!

Pay close attention to the product specifications you are looking to buy to make sure it fits your needs. 

orange square Your Budget

Some pizza stones cost more than others. A pizza stone’s price will vary depending on the product features and materials used to build the stone. Some manufacturers add coatings, handles, and specials materials to their baking stones, driving up prices.


Our Top Picks For Best Pizza Stones


bbq grill academyBest Overall: Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan With Loop Handles

We chose this cast iron baking pan because it will work well for most of our readers and perform well in just about any application. Cast iron baking pans can handle occasional drops as they are strong and can be used on your grill, stove, oven, and even open fires. Cast iron performs well due to its capability to retain heat; combine that with its strength and durability, and you have the top choice for most home and outdoor users.

We recommend cast iron baking pans because not only can you use these pans for baking pizza, but you can also use them for cooking other dishes and side items like meats and vegetables. Cast iron pans won out our vote due to their strength and versatility.

What we like:

  • Cast iron is strong and can handle a few drops without issue.
  • Absorbs, retains, and disperses heat well and quickly.
  • Versatile- can be used in ovens, grills, and open fire pits
  • Can be used to cook other meals such as meats and vegetables, not just pizzas.

What We Don’t Like:

  • Cast iron bakeware will always be on the heavier side.
  • Cast iron does require a bit of oil ( seasoning or maintenance ) to avoid rust.
  • Some cooking cast iron products can get damaged if exposed to extreme temperatures.

bbq grill academyBest for the Big Green Egg, Kamado Joe, and Primo Kamados: Cast Elegance Pizza Stone

This is cordierite pizza stone pick makes it to the top of our list because of the material used to build this stone (Thermarite). Cordierite is exceptionally resistant to high temperature and extreme temperature changes. These stones work great in kamado grills and even industrial-grade ovens. They can withstand extreme temperature shocks and changes, common when cooking outdoors and in a kamado grill burning at 700 degrees.

Cast Elegance pizza stones are built from a material they call Thermarite using cordierite stone, which is food safe, can absorb water from the pizza dough to bake crisp pizza dough, and is strong.

What We Like:

  • Durable Pizza Stone – more robust than other types of pizza stones
  • Good pizza stone for charcoal grill
  • It is very resistant to thermal shock, meaning if your stone is resting at room temperature and then is placed in your hot grill or oven, it won’t crack.
  • Pizza Stones do a great job at absorbing moisture from the pizza dough for crispier crusts.
  • Meets FDA and RoHS Standards, meaning the product is food safe and strict guidelines were followed during manufacturing.

What We Don’t Like:

  • It is a “STONE” it can crack and break with enough force
  • Stone bakeware can absorb oils and create oils spots on the stone, which are hard to clean

 

bbq grill academyBest for the Smoker: Unicook Heavy Duty Ceramic Pizza Grilling Stone

This cordierite baking stone is excellent for BBQ smokers, and since it is built from cordierite, it can withstand extreme heat for long periods of time and is durable. We like the shape of this stone for many reasons. It can handle a good-sized pizza and can be used in vertical gas propane or charcoal smokers or even as a cookie baking sheet in your oven. Its shape makes it very versatile around the kitchen. 

What We Like

  • Larger size for family pizza night
  • Works excellent in smoker grills due to its shape
  • It is a stone pan, so it will crisp pizza crust well

What We Don’t Like:

  • As with most stone bakeware, it can absorb oils and stain.
  • It can be harder to clean, especially since chemicals and soap are not recommended.

bbq grill academyBest for Gas Grill: Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone

The Flame Top pizza stone makes it to this list as the best pizza stone for gas grills as it can withstand up to 900 degrees and can be used on an open flame. The stone can be used on different heat sources, meaning you can use it in an oven, charcoal grill, or even fire pit.

This stone’s nicest feature is its coated or glazed surface which is micro-crazed to help bake your pizza to a crisp.

What We Like:

  • Easy to clean – in fact, this stone is dishwasher safe
  • Can endure up to 900 degrees – open flame
  • Its glazed coating makes it easy to clean, and grease and cheese won’t stick as much
  • The glaze coating protects the stone when cutting pizzas – scratch resistant
  • The handles help to move the stone in and out of the oven or grill – use gloves!

What We Don’t Like:

  • Oven Safe ONLY to 500 degrees
  • This stone is on the heavy side
  • The coating can chip or crack, so handle with care is required

bbq grill academyBest for the Oven: Wilton Perfect Results Non-Stick Crisper Pizza Pan

The Wilton Pizza pan is the best pan to use in home ovens or convection ovens. This pan is easy to use, and its non-stick surface makes it easier for beginners but still bakes crispy pizzas. This pizza pan is a good option for those who want to bake pizza in their oven and do not intent to bake their pizzas in any other place than their home oven.

What We Like:

  • These pizza pans are light and easy to move around
  • The non-stick surface makes it easier for beginners learning to bake pizzas
  • Material easy to clean – dishwasher safe
  • Great Value

What We Don’t Like:

  • Not as versatile as other pizza pans, this is mainly for your indoor kitchen oven only.

bbq grill academyBonus: Great Deal – Cuisinart CPS-445, 3-Piece Pizza Grilling Set, Stainless Steel

This pizza stone set is a great deal for those wanting to get started and learn how t bake pizzas at home. The Cuisinart Pizza Stone grilling set includes a Cordierite pizza stone, a pizza peel, and a pizza cutter. Everything you need to cook a fantastic pizza tonight!

What We Like:

  • Pizza Stone Great bundle for beginners – includes everything you need to cook your first pizza tonight
  • Ceramic Stone which works great in ovens, grills, and smokers

What We Don’t Like:

Hand wash only 🙁

One Last Word

Preparing and baking pizzas at home is a lot of fun and gratifying. Being able to pick your own toppings, pizza dough and add your own style is priceless. Pizza making can be a great Saturday night activity for the whole family, and it can be a better option to frozen pizzas. Try one of these stones and practice your craft, and soon, you will be making pizzeria quality pies! Don’t forget to invite your friends and family!

Enjoy life, get grilling.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on email
Share on print